Higher Performance Insights | BEHIND THE CURTAIN
Every Ballot Starts in a Classroom
Lost by 41. Here's who decided it.
"Kids these days just don't care."
You've heard it in a staff lounge. Maybe at a board meeting. Maybe in your own head at 9:40 on a Tuesday night.
Eleven days ago, the kids answered.
In 2024, 56% of young men voted for President Trump, according to AP VoteCast. On November 3, 59% of young men voted for Democrats in their House races, according to Tufts CIRCLE. Young voters overall went from a 14-point lean toward House Democrats to 35 points. Rural young people went from 60-38 Republican in 2024 to 50-44.
Same young people. Two years older. Two different parties. Zero new reasons to trust either one.
Both parties will spend the next year explaining what this means. I'll save them some consulting fees. Young Americans are loyal to results, and they've now fired both sides in back-to-back elections. The CBS News exit poll found that neither party is viewed favorably by a majority of voters. That's a performance review, and nobody got a raise.
I'm a raging moderate, so here's my claim. Argue with me in the comments. The most important civic institution in America is sitting in your district office and your president's suite right now, and it's been treating politics like weather. Something that happens to us. From the first day of pre-K to the last class of a degree, education leaders touch nearly every future voter in this country, most of them for 13 years or more. We should start acting like it.
The other ballot
Young people weren't the only ones voting on November 3. All over the country, communities also voted on their schools.
Two districts led by members of The PROOF Network lost school votes that night. One of them lost by 41 votes.
Forty-one. That's a couple of rows of bleachers at a JV volleyball game.
Those are swing voters too. The parent who skipped conferences. The neighbor who hasn't been inside the building since his own graduation. The 19-year-old who walked the stage in June and never got asked what he thought.
A school vote is a trust vote, and trust gets built years before anything lands on a ballot. Lose one by 41, and you learn exactly what each of those relationships was worth.
A Harley in a tunnel
For about ten years, American public life has sounded like a Harley-Davidson cracking the throttle in a tunnel. Deafening. Echoing. Impossible to think over.
Here's the thing about that noise. It's coming from a small number of bikes.
When More in Common mapped the country's political tribes, the two loudest poles, Progressive Activists and Devoted Conservatives, added up to 14% of Americans. The "Exhausted Majority" in the middle was about two-thirds.
Fourteen percent has been setting the volume for everybody. The rest of us have been standing in the tunnel with our hands over our ears, wondering why nobody can hear the kids.
Time to throttle down, brah. Sell the bike. Use the money to finish something. A degree, an apprenticeship, a welding ticket. The country could use the credential more than the exhaust note.
Nobody broke it. You inherited it.
Here's the part leaders don't say out loud, so I will. The system you run is broken, and you didn't break it.
Nobody did. Nobody sat in a room and designed an education system that loses boys in kindergarten, prices out the middle class at 18 and hands both a bill. It piled up one reasonable decision at a time over 50 years. A funding formula here. A transfer rule there. A tuition increase to cover a state cut. Each choice made sense in its year. Stack them up, and you get this:
- We made a degree the ticket. For two generations we told every kid that a bachelor's degree was the way into the middle class. Today, about 6 in 10 American adults don't have one (Census, 2024).
- Then we raised the price of the ticket. Americans now owe $1.86 trillion in student loans (Federal Reserve, Q2 2026).
- Then the public stopped trusting the venue. Only 38% of Americans have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in higher education, down from 42% a year ago. Cost is the top reason (Gallup, July 2026).
- And we keep changing the people at the top. The average college presidency lasted 5.9 years in 2022, down from 8.5 in 2006 (American Council on Education). We're asking for 18-year fixes from leaders who get six.
This week I wrote notes to several new college presidents. Each of them just started that 5.9-year clock. Their leadership teams will decide how long it runs.
So we sorted the country by credential, made the credential expensive, and then got surprised when the people who couldn't afford it got loud. That's a design flaw. Nobody gets to be the villain here, which is frustrating, because villains are so much easier to fire.
The road, Pre-K through PhD
A ballot is the last stop on a long road. By the time a 22-year-old walks into a polling place, he has already decided whether the system works for him. He decided it in pieces.
- Kindergarten. Boys start school less ready than girls, and the gap is widest in our poorest neighborhoods.
- The classroom. In 2020-21, 89% of public elementary teachers were women. A boy can go years without a man at the front of the room.
- Graduation. In the most recent estimate pooled across 37 states, 88% of girls finished high school on time. For boys, 82%.
- College. In 2024, 43% of women ages 18 to 24 were enrolled in college. For men, 34%.
- The drift. In 2023, 4.15 million Americans ages 16 to 24 were neither working nor in school.
- The cost. Men die deaths of despair, from suicide, drugs and alcohol, at nearly three times the rate of women.
Every gain girls and women earned over the last 50 years stays on the table. Women now earn about 58% of bachelor's degrees, and that's worth celebrating. Lifting boys and lifting girls belong in the same sentence. The goal is every young person crossing a stage, whether that stage holds a diploma, a journeyman card, or a doctoral hood.
Educational attainment is the closest thing this country has to a bipartisan solution, and we run it. Texas Superintendent of the Year Ginger Carrabine put it in five words: "Education is the greatest equalizer."
What we say that keeps the engine idling
Count how many of these you've heard this year:
• "Boys will be boys."
• "He'll grow out of it."
• "College just isn't for him." (Said about a ninth grader.)
• "That's the family's job."
• "We stay out of politics here."
• "Let's wait until things settle down after the election."
People say these with good intentions. Each one quietly moves a young person from our job to someone else's.
The fear underneath
Education leaders are tired. Tired of being dragged into the culture war, tired of board meetings that turn into cable news segments, tired of being the punching bag for both wings. So we go quiet and hope the bikes leave the tunnel.
I understand that. I hear it from superintendents and presidents every week, and I've asked the same question they ask on the drive home: is this work still worth it?
It is. And the work is apolitical in the best sense of the word. Reading, mentoring, and a real path after graduation have no party.
Third-grade reading has never once appeared on a ballot. It shapes every one of them.
Telescope, then microscope
Every afternoon at four, my team and I pick up two tools. The telescope shows the whole field. The microscope shows the people already in front of us.
The telescope on this election is loud: national margins, cable panels, both parties writing memos. The microscope is quieter. One third grader. One first-year student who stopped coming to class. One 41-vote margin.
Leadership teams change the telescope picture by working the microscope every week. Here's what that looks like up close.
Where it's already happening
What must happen is already happening. Here are six places where members of The PROOF Network and their teams have built it.
K-12 · Middleton, Wisconsin. Start with the kids. In 2024, two Middleton High School students started a food drive at a local grocery store. Today Meals Matter runs monthly drives and has grown to 19 chapters at high schools across the United States and South Korea. Superintendent Dr. Dana Monogue hands the credit right back: "Our students' strong leadership and advocacy have inspired students throughout our District, our state and around the world." Two high schoolers built that. So much for not caring.
K-12 · Uniondale, New York. Under Superintendent Dr. Dr. Monique Darrisaw-Akil, Uniondale became a New York State–recognized My Brother's Keeper community in 2021 and a nationally certified one in 2023. Students run MBK chapters at both middle schools and the high school. In Page Pals, teen mentors pair with third graders who need reading support. Teenagers teaching eight-year-olds to read is about the best rebuttal to "kids these days" I know.
K-12 · Pflugerville, Texas. Dr. Quintin Shepherd and his team made a promise they call the Three Es. By 2029, every Pflugerville ISD graduate, including students in special education and English learners, leaves with employment, enlistment or enrollment in hand. He says the work starts in pre-K. His line: "There are no lesser paths to a great education."
K-12 + higher ed · Dallas, Texas. Dallas College and nine school districts run 36 P-TECH high schools where students earn college credentials before they finish high school. From 2022 through the 2024-25 year, those students earned 3,885 credentials, from certificates to associate degrees. That kind of work takes campus presidents who see the high schools around them as partners. Two of them are PROOF Network members: Dr. Dr. Rick W. Smith Sr., CFRL, CCDP, president of North Lake, and Dr. Joe Seabrooks, who has led the Cedar Valley campus since 2016.
Higher ed, two-year to four-year · Cleveland, Ohio. Dr. Michael A. Baston, J.D., Ed.D. Tri-C partners with Cleveland State University on the Mandel Continuing Scholars pathway. 254 students have completed the Tri-C program, and 110 have gone on to CSU's honors college. The Mandel Foundation committed up to $6.8 million to the two schools, running into 2031.
Higher ed, four-year · St. Paul, Minnesota. Rev. Dr. Brian Friedrich and Concordia University, St. Paul just announced the nation's first Tuition Reset 2.0. Traditional undergraduate tuition drops $5,500 for 2027-28, to $21,700, the university's 2006 price. Remember that ticket we kept raising the price on? Concordia lowered it. Twice. CSP reports that after its first reset in 2013, enrollment grew 87% while Minnesota private colleges as a whole fell 18%. Friedrich's line: "Resetting our tuition for the second time opens the door for more students to access higher education."
None of these leaders waited for the tunnel to get quiet. They built something inside the noise.
Five moves for your leadership team
1. Take a beat and look at your own numbers. Pull your data for boys and girls side by side, from kindergarten readiness to graduation, or from entry to completion on a campus. Most teams have never seen it on one page. Say it in the room: "Show me our boys and our girls, or our men and our women, side by side, start to finish."
2. Give every drifting student one adult. In a district, that's the eighth grader whose attendance slipped in October. On a campus, it's the first-year student who quietly stopped coming to class. Mentoring works when someone checks on a student by name, every week. Say it: "Who on this team knows this student's name and will check on him Monday?"
3. Treat every path as a real path. Pflugerville's promise counts a job, the military, and college the same. Concordia cut its price so college stays on the list for more families. And this week we thanked our veterans: at Lone Star College in Houston, more than 4,700 of them are students right now. Enlistment and enrollment can be the same road. Say it: "Which of our pathways would we be proud to put our own kid in?"
4. Ask men to step into the room, and grow your own. Recruit men to teach, coach, advise, mentor and read with kids. Ask them directly, by name. Then build the pipeline at home. Bay Mills Community College in Michigan and Turtle Mountain College in North Dakota just opened a path for students to become math teachers without leaving their own communities. President Duane Bedell's line: "Partnerships like this demonstrate the strength of Tribal Colleges and Universities working together across Indian Country." Say it: "Who are three people in this community we haven't asked yet?"
5. Turn the volume down in your own building. Your community just came through a bruising election. Your leadership team can be the one room in town where the only question is what a young person needs. Say it: "If nobody in this room voted, what would we do for this student?"
The PROOF lens
Nearly 200 superintendents and presidents have sat down with me on The SHOW. The ones who stay and keep building share ten traits. I call them The PROOF. Three of them fit this moment almost too well.
Refuse to shrink the standard to fit the constraint. The constraints are real: a funding formula older than your seniors, $1.86 trillion in student debt, a public that trusts us a little less every year. Middleton, Uniondale, Pflugerville, Dallas, Cleveland and St. Paul kept the standard anyway.
Build rooms for listening, then act. Young voters just told both parties, two elections running, that nobody was listening. A leadership team that listens for 90 days and acts on day 91 gives them a different answer. So does a district that knows its 41 by name long before the next vote.
A bad season doesn't mean a bad calling. Ten loud years made for a rough season, and for some of you November 3 made it rougher. The calling is still there on Monday morning, in a third-grade classroom and a first-year seminar.
The leaders in the six bright spots above, from K-12 districts to community colleges and universities, are members of The PROOF Network, a circle of superintendents and presidents I've come to know through The SHOW and the work itself. Each of them is the proof that leading systems and people in education is worthy work.
Monday morning: the 30-minute Take a Beat
At your next leadership team meeting, set a timer.
- 10 minutes · Telescope. Put your data by gender on one page: boys and girls in a district, men and women on a campus. Everyone reads in silence and circles the number that bothers them most.
- 10 minutes · Microscope. Each leader names one student, or one group of students, drifting right now. Initials only.
- 10 minutes · Commit. For each one, decide who the adult is and what happens before next week's meeting.
Pushback 1: "We don't have the data broken out that way." Then that's your first finding. Ask your data lead for it by Friday.
Pushback 2: "This feels political." Ask the room which party is against third graders reading or first-generation students finishing. Then get back to work.
Bonus for district teams: Who are the 41 people in our community we haven't talked with since the last vote?
SCREENSHOT THIS
- Which young people in our system are drifting right now, and who knows their names
- Which of our pathways would we put our own kids in?
- Who are our 41?
- If nobody in this room voted, what would we do differently on Monday?
Your move this week
Run the 30-minute Take a Beat with your leadership team. Then come back to the comments and tell me one thing you found: the number that surprised you, or the path you'd fix first. (No student names, please.)
FROM DR. JOE
You inherited a system you didn't design, a public that's been shouting for a decade and a generation of young people who just told both parties they're not impressed. You hired best-in-class leaders to help you carry it. Then the pressure hits and the leadership team pulls apart, and the best people burn out.
That part can change. Your organization has spent years developing leaders. Higher Performance Group builds the team those leaders sit on. Team development is all we do.
Start with your people. The PROOF is the keynote that came out of those nearly 200 SHOW conversations: ten traits, real leaders' stories and protocols your leadership team can use the next morning. Every participant gets a companion guide. It sends people back to their buildings remembering why they said yes in the first place. If your spring convocation, leadership retreat or back-to-school kickoff needs that, let's find a date.
When your team is ready to go deeper, the Team Accelerator turns that energy into one shared way of working. Your team empowers each other, and your best people stay.
The kids are watching who shows up. So are the 41. When your team holds, your community sees a team worth trusting again.
If this one landed, repost it or send it to the one colleague who needs to read it before Monday.
Turn high performing leaders into a Higher Performing Team.
Higher Performance Group. The name in Team Development.
DR. JOE HILL ll · Higher Performance Group
Help Spread the Word
If you found value in this post, we’d love your help spreading the word! Please consider sharing this on your favorite social media platform and tag Higher Performance Group and Dr. Joe Hill. Your support helps us reach and inspire more awesome people like you!
Like What You've Read?
Get practical, research-based ideas to Accelerate
Higher Team Performance delivered straight to your inbox every Tuesday.
More Blog Articles



