The 5 Temptations Every Campus Leader Must Overcome

The 5 Temptations Every Campus Leader Must Overcome (Or Become the Joke at the Dinner Table)

May 2, 2023

Most leaders I know (and serve) are struggling and wish for a better reality.

“What happened to community trust?”
“How do I get my team back to full strength?”
“Since when did the arena of education become such a powder keg?”

The last few years have put that struggle into hyperdrive.

The current leadership landscape has twisted leaders into a bundle of tired and (at times) timid souls scrambling to find the skills and strategies they need to make progress.

There have been loads written about tactics to reclaim your momentum, but not enough people are honest to talk about the temptations that predictably show up to struggling leaders.

While ‘moral’ temptations are part of the equation, it’s more nuanced than that.

It’s easy to settle in and become hooked on maintaining the status quo when the going is easy, the numbers are decent, and nobody is breathing down your neck. Often to the point of cheating the practices and disciplines that built your winning trajectory.

It’s also easy to fall into lazy leadership in seasons of struggle. Regardless of the reason, when you’re in a slump, you’re tempted to cheat in ways you weren’t when things are going well.

Here’s what you’ll likely be tempted to do under sloth or stress that will cause your team to poke fun of you at their dinner table.

1. Moving the goalposts

Moving the goalposts signifies insecurity and is a horrible leadership strategy when uncertainty rules the day.

Great leaders and teams Plan, Do, Study, and ACT.

Not ACTING is a common temptation for leaders and teams responsible for leading systems.

What do you do when data that used to make you smile now shows decline instead of progress?

A natural response is to shut your eyes and stop looking.

Many leaders who track progress when their organization grows become immediately tempted to stop monitoring it when the growth stops.

That’s a mistake.

Even worse, some leaders will move the goalposts toward comfort vs. courage.

“Well, I know we used to track campus orientation visits, but that’s not important with everything else happening right now.”
“Let’s focus on the whole student experience instead of counting _________” (fill in the blank).

Can we be honest? You never used to say that.

Ever.

And everyone around you knows it.

When you pretend that metrics no longer matter, you’re setting yourself up to become a victim of accidentalism.

Intentionality and focus are the one-two punches for Higher Performance Systems.

Compromising your expectation by lazily moving the goalposts is a terrible leadership strategy.

Practical Strategies to Reclaim Your Momentum and
Transform Team Performance

Enroll in the Lead Team Institute for the 2023-2024 academic year and Optimize Higher Team Performance.

Enroll in the Lead Team Institute

2. Tamp Down the Vision

Another temptation leaders face when they’re struggling is to tamp down the vision.

Worse than moving the goalposts and changing how you keep score; average leaders are tempted to ignore the aims of the established vision for winning in the year ahead.

This happens in many ways, but it predominantly surfaces when campus leaders say they’re committed to EXCELLENCE but have no way of measuring what that means from the student experience.

Example: We’re about making dreams reality.

Translation: We are currently struggling to provide programming and new partnerships due to our fixed program of study that can’t be changed in our current political climate.

Example: Community is our middle name.

Translation: We would like to meet more of the local workforce demands, but that “W” word is not received well by the powerful voices of our faculty.

The best way to get off mission is to tamp down your vision by running for popularity over purpose.

3. Blame everyone but yourself

Poor leaders point blame. Higher Performance Leaders take responsibility.

It’s easy to blame others or forces beyond control when things are not going as hoped.

Here’s the whine list of excuses I hear from top leaders when things go south.

“Our underperformance is because of:”

➜ COVID

➜ Lockdown

➜ The Economy

➜ The Weather

➜ The Campus Down the Street

➜ Your City

➜ Your Culture

➜ The White House

➜ The Supreme Court

➜ The Faculty

➜ The Administration

➜ The Board

Anything but Themselves.

Blaming others is a clear sign of weakness (not strength) in a leader.

Deep down, most leaders know they have not lost ALL control.

Poor leaders deflect it. Great leaders own it.

4. Imagine yourself in a new system

When you’re struggling as a leader, it’s completely natural to want to escape.

You start to imagine yourself in a new job—any new job will do—and think about how much easier it might be if you did that rather than what you’re doing now.

The challenge with that thinking is that it leaks. Your people can sniff out when you start looking elsewhere.

The fact is that every new team and system has issues. Often, the grass looks greener on the other side because THEY have a remarkable marketing department and because YOU haven’t gotten close enough to see the brown blades interspersed with the green blades. Not to mention the root rot found across every human system.

Also, you bring yourself everywhere you go. This means you bring all your unresolved pain, challenges, unhealthy behaviors, and unresolved issues with you.

In many ways, leaving a job you’re unhappy with is like leaving a marriage you don’t like. You imagine a new partner will be perfect, which is completely untrue (see above). Unfortunately, you (and your new team) bring your dysfunction into whatever you decide to do next.

Granted, there are times you might be called to leave. To everything…turn…turn…turn…

No one stays in a job forever.

Here’s the Big Idea to remember. You want to quit on a good day, not a bad day. And seasons of struggle are filled with bad days.

If you’re not thinking clearly (and you’re not when you struggle), you’ll likely make a move you’ll regret later.

And because pain isolates you, you probably haven’t discussed this carefully with your wise people. You may be the only one who thinks leaving is a good idea. And if you’re the only one who thinks it’s a good idea, it’s probably not.

Curious about when it’s a good time to leave? Listen to these seven tell-tale signs:

You’ve lost your passion.
There are no new partnerships you could get excited about.
You’ve impacted all the changes you can make.
Your vision no longer lines up with the system’s vision.
You feel indifferent toward your team and community.
Your excitement about what’s happening elsewhere is greater than your interest in what’s happening where you are.
Your inner circle agrees that it is time for you to fly.

5. Dulling instead of dealing with pain

When stress (and life) knock, you will answer it in a healthy way (self-care) or an unhealthy way (self-indulgence).

Usually, when I ask busy campus leaders how they’re doing, they admit they don’t take great care of themselves.

When you don’t take great care of yourself, guess what you’ll do in almost every single case?

You end up falling into sensory indulgence —you soothe the pain with the “overs.”

Overeating
Over drinking
Overworking
Over-exercising

The list is endless. Sensory indulgence involves doing anything you can to numb the pain without actually addressing the pain.

When stress and life overwhelm you, you will either respond to it in a healthy way (self-care) or an unhealthy way (self-indulgence).

But here’s the stinger: If you don’t intentionally choose self-care as a leader, you’ll default to self-indulgence. Your team will know if the ladder is true, and so might their dinner table.

The key to getting out of the struggle begins with recognizing that you’re in it.

Understanding your temptations makes it easier to avoid making the struggle worse.

Semester II is when you start planning for Semester I

This is one of the best opportunities to begin planning to accelerate your team’s performance.

For the past decade, I have served campus Lead Teams and know your system's performance is directly connected to your team's health (and smarts).

❓How’s your team’s communication and connection?
❓How’s the quality of your system’s alignment and execution?
❓What’s your plan for optimizing your Lead Team’s capacity?

As THE people leader for your system, I invite you and your leadership team to consider enrolling in the Lead Team Institute {LTI} for the 2023-2024 academic year.

Here is a quick link for more info.

This national initiative is designed to Optimize Higher Team Performance:

✅ Team Communication
✅ Team Connection
✅ Team Alignment
✅ Team Execution
✅ Team Capacity
✅ Reliable Systems

Our fall kickoff dates are filling up. Schedule your preferred fall kick-off date here.

Ready to reclaim your momentum and optimize Higher Team Performance?

Secure your spot today!

Dr. Joe Hill - Founder, Higher Performance Group

“Because everyone deserves to live in a community served by healthy teams and highly reliable systems.”

< Older Post

Newer Post >

More Blog Articles

Higher Performance Insights | KNOW-IT-ALL SYNDROME IS BLEEDING TALENT

By HPG Info • June 17, 2025

Here's how campus leaders break the cycle Here's what nobody tells you about climbing the education ladder: Every rung makes learning feel more optional. Every promotion whispers that you've arrived. Every title suggests you should know, not grow. It's a trap. The thing about Maslow Most campus leaders know the hierarchy. Self-actualization sits at the top like a trophy. Except Maslow didn't stop there. Right before he died, he added level eight: self-transcendence. The recognition that your growth isn't about you—it's about enabling everyone else's growth. He knew something most campus leaders miss: The moment you stop learning, you start the slow leak of influence. THE NUMBERS DON'T LIE When campus leaders position themselves as chief learners instead of chief knowers: Faculty retention jumps 23%. Student outcomes improve 17%. Organizational resilience increases 35%. When they don't? Institutional influence drops 30% within three years. Your campus culture doesn't mirror what you say about learning. It mirrors what you do about learning. THE QUESTION THAT CHANGES EVERYTHING When was the last time your team saw you struggle with something new? Not struggle with budget constraints, board politics, or enrollment challenges. Those are management struggles—predictable, expected, part of the job description. When did they last see you wrestle with an idea? When did they witness your intellectual vulnerability? Here's the thing: Harvard's 2024 research shows that 70% of organizations believe leaders need to master a broader range of behaviors to meet current needs. In education's volatile landscape, intellectual rigidity isn't just limiting—it's dangerous. WHAT SELF-TRANSCENDENT LEADERS DO They get comfortable being uncomfortable. They attend lectures outside their expertise. They ask questions that reveal curiosity, not evaluation. They share their learning failures in real time. They understand that in a world where yesterday's best practices become tomorrow's compliance violations, learning agility is no longer a nice-to-have. It's survival. They know their learning gives them more influence than their title ever will. YOUR 90-DAY CHALLENGE What if—for the next 90 days—every campus leader publicly committed to learning something entirely outside their expertise? What if intellectual vulnerability at the top became permission for everyone else to adapt, grow, innovate? What if your next leadership meeting started with: "Here's what I learned this week that surprised me..." THE BRIDGE BUILDERS The longest bridge in the world spans 102 miles. It wasn't built with one heroic leap—it was constructed one careful span at a time. Campus leaders who thrive in uncertainty don't rely on a brilliant strategy; instead, they rely on a resilient mindset. They build learning habits. They model intellectual curiosity. They create cultures where growth is expected, not exceptional. They know that when the ground keeps shifting underneath everything else, the one constant is the need to keep learning how to build the next span. THE CHOICE You can be the campus leader who knows everything. Or you can be the one who learns everything. Only one of those creates the culture your students deserve. Only one of those builds bridges while the landscape changes. Only one of those recognizes that the most radical act in education today might just be admitting you don't know—and then doing something about it. What's something you learned recently that surprised you? Share it. Show your campus what learning leadership looks like. P.S. Most campus leadership teams operate at 60% of their potential. The {TQ}|Team Intelligence Assessment shows you how to unlock the other 40%. Five minutes per team member. Measurable results within six months. Because your campus deserves more than a collection of smart people, it deserves actual intelligence.

Higher Performance Insights | A MAD LIBS GUIDE TO STRATEGIC COURAGE

By HPG Info • June 11, 2025

How to Thread the Needle Between Progress and Funky Politics The longest bridge in the world spans 102 miles across the Danyang-Kunshan Grand Bridge in China. It wasn't built with one heroic leap—it was constructed one careful span at a time, each section tested and proven before the next began. As you sit in budget meetings with federal funding cuts looming and compliance investigations multiplying, that bridge isn't just an engineering marvel—it's your strategic blueprint for survival. Because in education today, yesterday's mainstream initiative can become tomorrow's federal investigation faster than you can say "equity audit." The Ground Is Moving Beneath Your Feet The new federal leadership has eliminated DEI initiatives, frozen federal grants, and directed the closure of the Department of Education. What was considered "acceptable" innovation six months ago may now be regarded as "radical." What seemed impossible is suddenly policy. Political scientist Joseph Overton identified how cultural acceptance shifts through what became known as the "Overton window"—the range of policies voters find acceptable at any given time. The Michigan-based Mackinac Center, where Overton worked, theorized that this window typically shifts gradually. However, we're witnessing something unprecedented: rapid, dramatic movements that compress decades of change into months. The current moment illustrates how quickly political boundaries can shift, transforming yesterday's fringe ideas into today's mainstream policies. Your strategic challenge isn't just adaptation—it's anticipation. Welcome to Educational VUCA Reality You're no longer managing regular strategic planning. You're navigating VUCA conditions—Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity, and Ambiguity—originally developed by the U.S. Army War College to describe post-Cold War strategic environments. Volatility: Federal funding freezes, Title IX reversals, and transgender sports bans hitting simultaneously across all educational levels. Uncertainty: Will Title I funding survive? Pell Grants dropping from $7,400 to $5,700? University endowments over $1 billion facing civil compliance investigations? Complexity: Special education funding shifting to block grants while maintaining "current levels," NIH grants paused, research costs capped at 15%. Ambiguity: Expand school choice while closing federal oversight. Promote "evidence-based" reading while eliminating professional development grants. Mixed messages aren't confusion—they're the new operating environment. Your Strategic Fill-in-the-Blank Framework Like Mad Libs, strategic prompts help you think creatively within structured boundaries. When political landscapes shift rapidly, ready frameworks keep you responsive rather than reactive (Senge & Edmondson, 2024): For K-12 Leaders: "What if we strengthened ______________ using only state and local resources before Title II funding disappears?" "How might we demonstrate student achievement gains without triggering federal investigations into our _______________ initiatives?" For Higher Ed Leaders: "What would happen if we reframed our diversity programming as ______________ student success initiatives?" "How do we maintain research momentum when ______________ federal funding streams face uncertainty?" These aren't prescriptions—they're thinking tools for navigating the "gotcha" landscape while maintaining your mission. The Professional Creative's New Reality Your job isn't to resist the tide, though values matter deeply. It's to be strategically creative—pushing just enough beyond the current window to serve students without triggering systems actively hunting for "radical" programs. The federal landscape reshapes rapidly, but your influence remains local. That's where your power lies—and increasingly, that power depends on your team's collective intelligence (Woolley et al., 2023). Navigating the Next 90 Days These are shifting landscapes with no clear roadmap. What follows aren't recommendations, but different lenses through which thoughtful leaders are viewing their challenges: What Some K-12 Leaders Are Exploring: Language emphasizing measurable outcomes—framing student support as academic acceleration Documentation highlighting concrete results rather than theoretical frameworks Strengthening local partnerships before federal resources become uncertain What Some Higher Ed Leaders Are Considering: Revenue diversification as traditional funding faces constraints Reexamining how student services are described and delivered Proactive compliance reviews, especially for institutions with significant endowments What Many Find Helpful: Building initiatives defensible through multiple political lenses—student achievement, family strengthening, and economic development. The key isn't perfect answers, but flexibility to adapt as circumstances evolve. This isn't about abandoning principles or playing politics. It's about finding sustainable ways to serve your mission when the ground keeps shifting. Your Strategic Courage Moment Leaders who successfully navigate these waters discover that careful, thoughtful approaches create space for others to find their own path forward. The opportunity lies not in perfect safety or bold risks, but in persistent creativity that builds bridges while the landscape around you changes. In environments like this, transformation comes less from brilliant strategy than from steady courage-the kind that spreads when others see it's possible to move forward thoughtfully, even in uncertainty. Research consistently demonstrates that team performance, not individual brilliance, determines institutional success in navigating turbulent waters (Deloitte, 2023). Your Next Steps: Audit your language. How would your current initiatives sound if described through achievement, family, or economic development lenses? Diversify your support. What local partnerships could replace federal dependencies? Document strategically. How do you measure impact in ways that translate across political perspectives? Build bridges, not monuments. Every program should be defensible as supporting student success—language that travels well in any political climate. The longest bridge in the world exists because engineers built it one tested span at a time. Your educational mission deserves the same careful and persistent attention. Your students need you to be strategically courageous—not reckless, not paralyzed, but thoughtfully bold enough to keep building bridges while the ground shifts beneath your feet. Because transformation doesn't require genius in this environment. It requires strategic courage—and the wisdom to know that sometimes the most radical act is building something that lasts. Unlock Your Team's Full Potential The cost of waiting is too high. Every day your team operates at less than full potential represents lost opportunities for your students and institution. Research indicates that most campus leadership teams operate at only 60% of their full potential (Higher Performance Group, 2024). Take the {TQ}|Team Intelligence Assessment In just five minutes per team member, discover actionable insights that have been demonstrated to improve team performance by an average of 27% within six months. The TQ Assessment reveals how your team can leverage cognitive diversity to transform from talented individuals into a truly intelligent collective. Your Next Steps: Assess Your Team's Intelligence : Take the comprehensive TQ assessment and receive your personalized team analysis within 48 hours Discover Your Path Forward : Schedule your complimentary TQ report review with a certified consultant Blueprint Your Success : Develop your practical 90-day plan to upgrade your team's performance